Honest book reviews + free, legal public-domain classics. Join our weekly email →

The Gate of the Feral Gods by Matt Dinniman – book cover

The Gate of the Feral Gods: Dungeon Crawler Carl Book 4

By Matt Dinniman

Dark Fantasy, Genre Fiction, Horror

The next level promises a simple mission—but nothing in the dungeon is ever simple. In *Dungeon Crawler Carl*, Carl and his team face the fifth floor, where four impossible castles stand between them and the next stage: a floating fortress, a sand-built stronghold, a broken submarine, and a haunted crypt filled with deadly traps. With time running out, they must work alongside other trapped crawlers to survive—but trusting the wrong person could be just as dangerous as the monsters they face. A chaotic mix of strategy, humor, and brutal survival awaits.

Release Date
2021
Available at:

We may earn a commission if you buy through these links, at no extra cost to you.

Our Review

About the book

The fourth installment of the LitRPG series follows Carl and his cat companion Princess Donut deeper into an alien game show’s deadly dungeon built beneath Earth’s ruins. A new floor brings fresh rules, rival crawlers and the meddling of gods, as the alien audience and corporate overseers raise the stakes.

Our review

Carl and Donut descend again, and the series gets bigger, stranger and more politically barbed with every floor.

By book four Dinniman has fully committed to expanding his world beyond the dungeon’s traps and monsters. The behind-the-scenes politics of the alien show, the factions vying for influence and the gods with their own agendas give the story a wider scope, while Carl’s simmering rage against the system gives it a spine. The comedy is still loud and gleefully crude, and Donut remains a scene-stealer.

The scale comes at a cost: the cast is now large, the game mechanics more complicated, and the stat screens and item descriptions can slow the momentum for readers who are not into LitRPG conventions. Some new characters get less development than they deserve. Fans will relish the escalation, though, and the book’s darker undercurrent about entertainment built on suffering hits harder here.

What we loved

  • World-building expands in satisfying, surprising ways
  • Princess Donut is funnier than ever
  • Sharper satire of exploitative entertainment

Keep in mind

  • Game mechanics and menus can bog down pacing
  • Growing cast spreads character work thin

Read it if you like

The Wandering Inn, Hitchhiker’s Guide fans, readers who loved the earlier Carl books

The verdict

A bigger, bolder installment that deepens the series’ satire while keeping its manic, profane fun intact.

Author

Matt Dinniman